Using ChatGPT for behavioral health assessment, diagnosis, and treatment planning introduces several risks related to biases inherent to all artificial intelligence (AI). This is especially true with ChatGPT, the type of AI that is most likely used by healthcare providers. It’s crucial to recognize that while ChatGPT offers promising capabilities, it is not immune to perpetuating or amplifying existing biases. These biases can stem from various sources, including the data used for training, the algorithms employed, and the context in which the AI is deployed. The sections below provide an overview of the significant risks of ChatGPT and AI bias in assessment, diagnosis, and treatment planning in mental health and substance use.
Types of AI Biases
Data Bias and Representation
- Problem. Biases can emerge from imbalanced or incomplete datasets that do not adequately represent diverse populations. AI models trained on skewed data may lead to underrepresentation or misrepresentation of certain demographic groups, resulting in inaccurate diagnoses and treatment recommendations for those groups.
- Solution. Curating diverse and representative datasets is essential to mitigate data bias. This involves ensuring adequate representation across various demographic factors such as age, gender, race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and geographic location.
Sociocultural AI Bias
- Problem. AI models can inadvertently inherit societal biases present in the training data. These biases may be related to cultural norms, stereotypes, or historical disparities. As a result, diagnosis and treatment suggestions may not be appropriate for patients from different cultural backgrounds.
- Solution. Regularly evaluating AI models for sociocultural biases and retraining them with diverse and unbiased data can help address this issue. Involving experts from diverse backgrounds in model development and evaluation is also crucial.
Diagnostic AI Bias
- Problem. AI algorithms might rely on patterns in historical diagnostic decisions, which can perpetuate biases that clinicians might exhibit. For instance, if there are disparities in the diagnosis of certain conditions based on gender, an AI trained on such data might amplify these discrepancies.
- Solution. Continuous oversight and refinement of AI models are necessary to identify and correct diagnostic biases. Implementing feedback loops involving clinicians and experts can aid in aligning AI diagnoses with evolving medical best practices.
Feedback Loop AI Bias
- Problem. Biased AI recommendations can lead to biased clinical decisions. If AI-guided recommendations are consistently followed, they may reinforce existing biases over time, making correcting them in the long run difficult.
- Solution. Encouraging healthcare professionals to assess AI recommendations critically, seek second opinions, and use AI as a tool rather than a sole decision-maker can help prevent feedback loop bias.
Stigmatization and Labeling
- Problem. Biased AI diagnoses can inadvertently stigmatize individuals, affecting their mental well-being and access to appropriate care. Incorrect labels or diagnoses may lead to unnecessary treatments or neglect of necessary interventions.
- Solution. Providing clear explanations of the AI’s limitations and encouraging open communication between patients, clinicians, and AI systems can help mitigate stigmatization.
AI Bias Discussion Conclusion
While AI and ChatGPT hold immense potential for enhancing mental health and substance use diagnosis and treatment planning, the risks of AI biases cannot be ignored. A comprehensive approach involving diverse and representative data, ongoing model evaluation, and collaboration between AI developers, clinicians, and cultural experts is paramount to address these risks. An example of such collaboration is presented in the introductory literature review of this Telehealth.org article: ChatGPT Diagnosis: Walking the Tightrope of Legality and Ethics. It’s important to acknowledge that AI should complement, rather than replace, the expertise and empathy of clinicians.
If this evolving area interests you, get involved here at Telehealth.org (write to us), in your professional organizations, or by scanning the Internet or social media for professional groups to join.
Therapist AI & ChatGPT: How to Use Legally & Ethically
Immerse yourself in our highly-engaging eLearning program and delve into the uncharted territory of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Behavioral Healthcare!
Telehealth 101: Essential Telehealth Technology Orientation
In this 2.5 hour, basic technology training, you will find a well-organized discussion of relevant basic research along with practical suggestions for making foundational decisions about your digital practice with cloud storage, backups systems, security software such as VPNs, HIPAA compliance and software purchasing, synchronous and asynchronous technologies, and much more.
Telehealth Clinical Best Practices Course Bundle
This Telehealth Advanced Clinical Course Bundle provides the most important clinical risk management and telehealth compliance training available anywhere to help with clinical decisions and documentation, regardless of the size of your telehealth services.